Call Us Now
888-842-4344

About Us


First Choice Insurance is a family owned and operated insurance agency dedicated to providing quality insurance solutions to clients near Poplar Bluff, MO. We combine our strong insurance background and product knowledge to assist both current and future clients in managing and planning for all types of risk.

Our team of insurance professionals has years of collective industry experience writing both personal and commercial insurance policies designed to fit your needs. You'll be paired with a professional at First Choice Insurance who will work to ensure that you receive personalized attention you deserve.

When you work with First Choice Insurance, you'll experience the quality service and attention to detail that you can only find with an independent insurance agency.

Our Locations

*Poplar Bluff - Headquarters

1359 N. Westwood Blvd
Poplar Bluff, MO 63901
Main office: 573-535-6675
Toll free: 888-842-4344

Cape Girardeau Location

1319 N Mount Auburn Rd.
Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Main office: 573-271-2170

Caruthersville Location

713 Ward Ave.
Caruthersville, MO 63830
Main office: 573-333-0780

Columbia Location

3610 Buttonwood Dr. Ste 100
Columbia, MO 65201
Main office: 573-874-6464

Perryville Location

18 W Sainte Maries St. Suite 1
Perryville, MO 63775
Main office: 573-517-5010

Springfield Location

2760 S Kansas Expy.
Springfield, MO 65807
Main office: 417-708-9106

Our Providers

Testimonials

"From my first appointment...I MATTERED, and YOU WILL TOO."
Tonya Furgeson
"Thank you to everyone at First Choice, Steve you have a great group. if you want good service when things are most difficult, think First Choice Insurance."
Steve Naff
"Great people!! Always done our business right!"
Senya Dobbs
"As always, I was treated in a positive, professional way from all of the staff! I have multiple policies with them from different carriers. Could not speak any higher of the group! Excellent!!"
Randy Kincy