Call Us Now

Request A Free Quote

Get A Quote

Our Family Protecting Your Family

Click Here For Questions About Affordable Care Act

As a family owned and operated insurance company First Choice Insurance has delivered custom insurance solutions to individuals in Missouri and Arkansas, specializing in Auto, Homeowners, Business and Farm insurance coverage. Our team of experienced insurance professionals is committed to helping you find a policy that fits your needs. We focus on providing personalized attention and quality customer service to create an experience that's difficult to find in today's market. At First Choice Insurance, we'll work with you to ensure that you and those you care about most are protected.

We proudly provide insurance solutions to clients near Poplar Bluff, Dexter, Cape Girardeau, Wappapello, Doniphan, and Neelyville, Missouri.



If anyone reading this in on the fence about whether they want to give First Choice Insurance a chance to show them how they can HELP them, then I'm here to tell you to GET OFF THAT FENCE. For 10 years I've felt like I've been held a prisoner of a deception that was done to us the day we bought our house. But NO MORE. For 10 years I have struggled to try and get any type of quality customer service with our insurance. But NO MORE. For 10 years I felt like I really didn't matter to my insurance company. I was no more than a dollar sign to them. But NO MORE. To be honest, I came to FCI because someone I knew, trusted, and respected went to work for them and I wanted to support this person if I could at all. But I didn't want to "jump from the frying pan into the fire." I have had such a wonderful experience with FCI, and have felt actual, genuine concern for me and my needs. And that has been quite refreshing. Not only did they work relentlessly to find me better insurance than I previously had, they saved me money. A LOT of money. They went out of their way to stay in contact with me and let me know what was going on and always treated me with respect. You just can't lose with FCI. I will tell everyone to give you a chance to HELP them like you HELPED me. "From my first appointment...I MATTERED, and YOU WILL TOO." ~Tonya Ferguson
Tonya Furgeson
Hitting a deer is something of a regular happening, but this was my first time in 47 years of driving. All of the crew at First Choice were just wonderful. It is never a good time, but the Christmas holidays were particularly tough; getting the rental, repairs and such efficiently could have been a disaster form my travel plans. They worked with me to make it a good experience, in spite of the accident. Thank you to everyone at First Choice, Steve you have a great group. And Baileys did a fantastic job on the repair. Looks brand new, just like when I drove it off the car lot. My thoughts; if you want good service when things are most difficult, think First Choice Insurance. They really go to work to make the best of a bad situation.
Steve Naff

Our Location

First Choice Insurance Agency

1359 North Westwood Blvd
Poplar Bluff, MO 63901
Main office: 573-535-6675
Toll free: 888-842-4344