Call Us Now

Welcome MBT Clients To The First Choice Family

We Are Moving! Starting August 1st, our Perryville location will now be at 1418 West Saint Joseph Street, Perryville, MO 63775. 

Our Family Protecting Your Family

First Choice Insurance has been serving the Poplar Bluff area for over 20 years. We have received specific training in Life Insurance and financial services and are Affordable Care Act trained and certified.  In our commercial department we have a Church specialist that understands the needs of the local church and tailors coverage meet the needs of the ministry.

FCI is a proud supporter of the Poplar Bluff School System and Student Activities; sponsoring the Boy's Basketball Halftime- Half Court Shot, Project Graduations, and many other programs.  FCI supports many charities, such as Ozark Family Resource Agency, as well as many church events and causes.

No business account is too large or too small for First Choice Insurance. Factories, garages, clinics, restaurants, repair shops, HVAC, retail stores, beauty shops and more. "FCI is one of the areas fastest growing insurance agencies because of their commitment to excellence and dedication to customer care." Contact us today to see how we can help you, your family and your business!

We proudly provide insurance solutions to clients near Poplar Bluff, Dexter, Cape Girardeau, Wappapello, Doniphan, and Neelyville, Missouri...

Call us today at (573) 686-2870 or contact an agent today!

Like, Share, Follow:



FINRA Broker Check


"From my first appointment...I MATTERED, and YOU WILL TOO."
Tonya Furgeson
"Thank you to everyone at First Choice, Steve you have a great group. if you want good service when things are most difficult, think First Choice Insurance."
Steve Naff
"Great people!! Always done our business right!"
Senya Dobbs
"As always, I was treated in a positive, professional way from all of the staff! I have multiple policies with them from different carriers. Could not speak any higher of the group! Excellent!!"
Randy Kincy

Our Locations

*Poplar Bluff - Headquarters

1359 N. Westwood Blvd
Poplar Bluff, MO 63901
Main office: 573-535-6675

Perryville Location

1418 W Saint Joseph St.
Perryville, MO 63775
Main office: 573-517-5010